94

19

News

Government plans to ban smoking scenes in K-dramas raise questions about on-screen alcohol, drugs, and violence

AKP STAFF
Posted by Janie-Reign Sunday, February 4, 2024

Netizens are puzzled by the South Korean government's recent announcements regarding media censorship.

On February 4, Herald Corporation reported that Netflix and other online video streaming services (OTT) are facing criticism for exposing smoking scenes without restrictions, which is believed to encourage youth smoking. In response to these concerns, the South Korean government intends to suggest limiting the depiction of smoking scenes to the World Health Organization (WHO).

The South Korean Ministry of Health and Welfare has disclosed its participation in the 10th Conference of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) set for later this month. Their aim is to implore member countries to adopt measures to curtail the portrayal of tobacco and smoking scenes across OTT platforms and other mediums.

Currently, in K-dramas and entertainment shows, smoking scenes are either omitted or discreetly blurred out, but on OTT platforms, such scenes are exposed without any specific restrictions. Media outlets are taking the Netflix drama 'Doona!' as an example, where the protagonist, played by Suzy, is frequently seen smoking to reflect the original webtoon.

Meanwhile, netizens took to the comments section on media platforms and addressed this issue with reference to other forms of depictions in media. Many voiced their opinions that cigarettes tend to get a relatively bad reputation in Korea when compared with alcoholic drinking, drug use, and violence. 

Specifically, the leniency in South Korean media towards the portrayal of drinking culture and alcoholism has come under scrutiny. Korean netizens remarked that "if regulations are necessary for on-screen smoking, then they should apply equally to drinking and drug use."

Reactions from Korean netizens include:


"Why are they cracking down on smoking scenes when there are countless scenes of characters drinking excessively and engaging in violent acts every day? What a strange country. If they're going to censor smoking scenes, then they should also censor the heavy drinking scenes."

"They include scenes of cutting open stomachs and hitting others with axes but they find cigarettes problematic?"

"Drugs are okay but cigarettes are not? What a strange country"


"LOL K-dramas never ever problematize the issue of drinking alcohol"

"There are many scenes nowadays that depict having fun after drug use; compared to this, smoking a cigarette is nearly wholesome"

"Endless commercials of alcohol in the media but they do not allow cigarette commercials...I think they need to put those images of DUI accidents on bottles of alcohol just like the cigarette packets"

"I don't smoke or drink, but I can't fathom why it's acceptable to thematize murder, fraud, sexual abuse, bullying, and domestic violence as content in dramas and films, while they only seem concerned about cigarettes. There are far more cases of sexual assault linked to alcohol than cigarettes. Shouldn't they ban that as well?"

What are your thoughts?

  1. misc.
  2. Suzy
75 14,291 Share 83% Upvoted
 
starmygeneoa
starmygeneoa3,778 pts Sunday, February 4, 2024 7
Sunday, February 4, 2024

Once again, the drinking problem that the country as a whole has is conveniently ignored.

50 (+55 / -5)
Share

7 more replies

 
blue1997
blue19973,669 pts Sunday, February 4, 2024 2
Sunday, February 4, 2024

Watched “the worse evil” and the amount of smoking in that drama made my lungs hurt from just watching. Also “Samdalri” had way too much drinking. I don’t think showing smoking, drinking, etc needs to be completely removed maybe just have the script show the negative sides instead of people enjoying or making it “cool” or drinking every time something happens

14 (+21 / -7)
Share

2 more replies

SHOW ALL COMMENTS

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
Kal So Won
misc.
J.Y. Park, Wendy
JooE
Jang Na Ra, Kim Tae Ri
GFriend (Girlfriend)
Clara
Joo Won, Kim Min Jae, Kwak Do Won, Lee Joon Hyuk , Lee Yoo Young, Yoo Jae Myung
Kim Na Young
J.Y. Park, Wendy
J.Y. Park, Wendy
Kim Na Young
misc.
Joo Won, Kim Min Jae, Kwak Do Won, Lee Joon Hyuk , Lee Yoo Young, Yoo Jae Myung
Kal So Won
New Message

SEND