125

73

News
Posted by Susan-Han Thursday, August 24, 2023

'Dispatch' tests the note sequence between Jungkook's 'Seven' & Fin.K.L's 'Time of Mask' to find no overlapping components

AKP STAFF

On August 24 KST, media outlet 'Dispatch' published its findings after investigating the plagiarism accusations against BTS member Jungkook's solo single "Seven", originally raised by producer Yang Joon Young of Fin.K.L's "Time of Mask". 

Earlier this week, the plagiarism allegations raised by Yang Joon Young were made public via multiple news outlet reports, piquing the interest of the masses. Yang claimed that while the two songs used different keys, they still used the same note/scale sequence within a 4-bar section. 



The "problematic" section of "Seven", according to Yang Joon Young, is between 00:55~01:03, with lyrics beginning with "You love when I jump right in. All of me I'm offering...". In "Time of Mask", the supposed similar section is between 00:52~01:10.

To confirm Yang Joon Young's claims, 'Dispatch' experimented by transferring the music onto a blank music sheet. However, 'Dispatch' found that because "Seven" uses an Emaj scale while "Time of Mask" uses a B♭m, it is difficult to convert the two songs into a form with a completely matching key. 



Still, 'Dispatch' proceeded to convert "Seven" into a C key, and "Time of Mask" into an Am key. 

The media outlet concluded that there were no exactly overlapping components to the two songs, whether it involved key, chord progression, tempo, or the arrangement of notes. 

One expert told 'Dispatch', "To consider the possibility of plagiarism, at least two overlapping components must be found, such as the melody and the chord progression are the same. In this case, there are no overlapping components to be found." 

Shop the story
BTS JIN : VOGUE October 2024
$25
BTS JIN Cover - W Magazine August 2024
$24
  1. BTS
  2. Jungkook
  3. Fin.K.L
44 32,517 Share 63% Upvoted
 
parkjmsmyfilter
parkjmsmyfilter31 pts Thursday, August 24, 2023 0
Thursday, August 24, 2023

You don't remotely have to know music to tell this claim was BS, especially considering he ripped off the Spice Girls. The nerve of this guy is WILD.

17 (+21 / -4)
Share
 
Woteva
Woteva87 pts Thursday, August 24, 2023 0
Thursday, August 24, 2023

Dispatch asked for the opinion of an outside composer on this situation, and the composer stated that plagiarism dispute is nonsense.


"There are a total of only 12 notes (including sharps). Because of that, there are countless songs that include similar notes.


At least two factors, such as the melody or the chords, must match to bring up the discussion of plagiarism. However, the two songs here are completely different. The plagiarism dispute is nonsense."


— Composer “B”

15 (+29 / -14)
Share

SHOW ALL COMMENTS

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
Jiyeon
Min Hee Jin, NewJeans
Lee Jung Jae, Lim Ji Yeon
Buzz
V
Lee Da Hae
Lee Si Young
Big Bang, Taeyang, G-Dragon, Daesung
Lee Sang Soon
TWS
Big Bang, Taeyang, G-Dragon, Daesung
misc.
Kim Da Mi
V
Kim Nam Gil
New Message

SEND