171

50

News

"K-pop is singing in Korean," BLACKSWAN is praised after stating their opinions about K-pop

AKP STAFF
Posted by Sophie-Ha Wednesday, June 14, 2023

BLACKSWAN has recently garnered much attention since last year as "The first K-pop girl group in South Korea without any Korean members." 

The group's predecessor was originally a multinational girl group, 'Rania,' a mixture of Korean members and members from Thailand and Vietnam. However, due to the continued withdrawal of members, in 2020, three Korean members, Vietnamese Leah and Paturo members, were reorganized and re-debuted as BLACKSWAN. 

Thereafter,  all Korean members eventually left the group again. Gabi, Sriya, and Nvee joined last year, and Leia stopped promoting due to health reasons, currently making BLACKSWAN a four-member group.

Some ask them, "Why are they K-pop?" Recently, in the music industry, there has been a debate on whether a group without Koreans can really be called a K-pop group.

However, the group stated, "K-pop is singing in Korean, showcasing great songs and dances. Do you need any more explanation?” Sriya said that she studied traditional and modern dance in India and prepared to become a Bollywood backup dancer.  She explained, “I was surprised when I first saw a K-Pop performance, which showcases intense choreography and singing at the same time. Actually, in Bollywood, singing and dancing are separated. It felt like I had discovered a new possibility.”

The girls stated that "K-pop's identity lies, of course, mainly in the Korean language." Therefore the members worked hard studying Korean. Fatou explained, "The other members learned Korean through books so they can speak honorifics but I learned Korean through friends, so it's hard." She added, "I almost made a big mistake when I spoke casually with one of the producers during an important meeting for broadcast."

After reading BLACKSWAN's latest interview, Korean netizens were impressed with the group's perspective on K-pop and admired the members for diligently studying Korean.

K-netizen commented, "Wow, they're good," "The song is really good too," "They're pretty impressive trying to learn Korean," "This is the process in which K-pop is becoming just a genre," "What they say is true, if they sing in Korean, it's K-pop. If they sing in English it's pop," "The song is good," "The song is very K-pop," and "I agree with what they said about K-pop."

  1. BLACKSWAN
150 42,895 Share 77% Upvoted
 
Kflopstar
Kflopstar488 pts Wednesday, June 14, 2023 15
Wednesday, June 14, 2023

It's only the international K stans who discredit them because they love to fetishise east Asians, particularly Koreans. Blackswan are from a Korean agency, they trained in Korea, sing in Korean and they actively promote in Korea.... Not to mention 3/4 of the group can speak Korean.

48 (+66 / -18)
Share

15 more replies

 
Stray-Nana
Stray-Nana139 pts Wednesday, June 14, 2023 12
Wednesday, June 14, 2023

Honestly, it reminds me of how I got wth when Butter won on music shows... like, Butter isn't K-pop, it's American pop sung by Korean singers (no hate here)

33 (+42 / -9)
Share

12 more replies

SHOW ALL COMMENTS

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
misc.
Kal So Won
J.Y. Park, Wendy
JooE
Jang Na Ra, Kim Tae Ri
Joo Won, Kim Min Jae, Kwak Do Won, Lee Joon Hyuk , Lee Yoo Young, Yoo Jae Myung
Kim Na Young
J.Y. Park, Wendy
Lia
misc.
J.Y. Park, Wendy
misc.
Kal So Won
BTS, Jungkook
Kim Na Young
New Message

SEND