74

42

News
Posted by Janie-Reign Sunday, May 12, 2024

NewJeans' 'Bubble Gum' sparks debate over sampling versus plagiarism for similarity to an older song

AKP STAFF

Netizens are discussing a recent debate concerning NewJeans' "Bubble Gum."

On an online forum, discussions have erupted after a YouTube video drew parallels between "Bubble Gum" and the 1980s track "Easier Said Than Done" by British jazz-funk band Shakatak, still active today. The post, titled "Is this a plagiarism by NewJeans?" highlighted similarities between the compositions by 250 and others, and Shakatak's track by Bill Sharpe & Roger Odell.

The video has since garnered over 85,000 views and sparked thousands of comments.

Defenders of the song argue that sampling is a common practice in the music industry, noting that beats and samples can be legally acquired. Some suggest that "Bubble Gum" might have legally sampled the well-known Shakatak song, which itself has been used in multiple tracks, including Japanese commercials.

While ADOR has not yet confirmed whether "Bubble Gum" involves a licensed sample from "Easier Said Than Done," supporters insist that legally purchased samples do not require crediting the original artists. It's also reported that the Shakatak track has been sampled in about 20 other songs.

The Korean media's coverage of this controversy has since been retracted.

Discussion comments range from anticipation of an official release and statement to frustrations over misinterpretations of sampling laws:

"The song 'Bubble Gum' isn't even out on music platforms"

"So they haven't issued an official statement yet?"

"I wonder if this is corporate's way of trying to take down Min Hee Jin even more"
"The journalist who has written this article also wrote so many other articles talking about how Min Hee Jin said 'BTS "copied" her'...oh god"

"I'm so frustrated because once the sampling is cleared then there's no need to credit the owner of the original copyright, no?"
"So, it's like a remake?"
"There was a time when ATEEZ's producer EDEN had to post a message saying how their song "Dancing Like Butterfly Wings" used the same sample as PENTAGON's "Genius." But those samples were all legally purchased so it didn't matter..."

"It's too similar, ADOR will probably make a statement, right? Usually, ADOR is pretty clear about their position on such matters. But if it's just a reference, that would be a bit ridiculous since other groups get severely criticized for using references"
"I guess some people still don't understand the difference between sampling and plagiarism lol"
"ILLIT's 'Lucky Girl Syndrome' is also from sampling..."

SEE ALSO: "They won't be able to perform any of their old songs," Legal expert gives insight regarding NewJeans members filing lawsuit to void exclusive contract with ADOR

Shop the story
New Jeans Cover : Billboard Artist Magazine
$38
[WEVERSE POB] NewJeans - 2nd Single [How Sweet] (Standard ver.) (SET)
$125
  1. NewJeans
141 26,653 Share 64% Upvoted
 
Shuturtrap
Shuturtrap8,406 pts Sunday, May 12, 2024 5
Sunday, May 12, 2024

Same beat same flow different lyrics. You be the judge. Sounds like plagiarism to me unless they sampled the original or paid the original to use their beat

31 (+40 / -9)
Share

5 more replies

 
Lejan
Lejan2,582 pts Sunday, May 12, 2024 59
Sunday, May 12, 2024

This is what happens when you make "THEY'RE COPYING MEEEEEE!!!😭" the entire basis for your argument. Any legal sample, anything that looks or sounds like someone else suddenly becomes a problem for you.

Min Hee Jin did NewJeans dirty by crying about how the Y2K look and sound she didn't invent was being copied. She's set these poor girls up for online attacks and it's wrong.

23 (+52 / -29)
Share

59 more replies

SHOW ALL COMMENTS

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
BTS, EXO, Kang Ho Dong, Kim Ji Won, Kim Soo Hyun, Yoo Jae Suk
Hyun Bin, Son Ye Jin
Lee Jang Woo
aespa, Winter, ENHYPEN, Jungwon
Yoo In Na
Seventeen, Hoshi
Hyunjoo, Kim Woo Seok
Super Junior, Kyuhyun
BTS, EXO, Kang Ho Dong, Kim Ji Won, Kim Soo Hyun, Yoo Jae Suk
misc.
BTS, J-Hope, Crush
BABYMONSTER
FIFTY FIFTY
misc.
EXID, Hani
New Message

SEND