67

9

News
Posted by Sophie-Ha Thursday, December 21, 2023

K-netizens share their thoughts on the disappearing roles of dedicated positions like vocalist, rapper, dancer, and more

AKP STAFF

K-netizens have recently expressed their opinions on the vanishing trend of specialized roles such as vocalist, rapper, dancer, and leader within an idol group. 

In the K-pop industry, groups traditionally featured members with designated roles, each specializing in specific areas like vocals, dance, or rap. This structure shaped the group's dynamics and highlighted each member's distinct talents, allowing fans to appreciate their individual skills.

However, recent K-pop trends have shifted towards more versatile idol groups. Today's artists are increasingly expected to be all-rounders, adept in various facets of performance and entertainment. This move away from strict specialization allows members to develop a wider range of abilities and demonstrate versatility in their careers.

While this evolution represents a more all-around approach to talent development, it has sparked mixed reactions. Some Korean netizens express concerns that this jack-of-all-trades trend may dilute the unique individuality that once defined K-pop groups, impacting the industry more negatively than positively.

One netizen wrote, "When a talented group doesn't have specific positions, then I would think, 'they must all be talented,' but if a group that is less skillful does that, what crosses your mind is, 'there doesn't seem to be anyone talented enough to be designated as the main vocalist'."

In response to the post, K-netizens commented, "A group that doesn't have specific positions seems to mean the group lacks members with standout talent. They might say, they want multifaceted members but it makes it seem like no one is exceptionally talented in anything," "Honestly, listening to songs from a group without a main vocal is annoying. It feels like I'm listening to some advertisement song, not a full song," "I agree," "I agree with this post. Everyone starts to be similar to each other," and "I totally agree. If a group that's not that talented doesn't have specific positions, then I think 'oh...that's not surprising'," and "I can think of a few groups... lol."

What are your thoughts on this topic? Let us know in the comments below!

  1. misc.
55 12,632 Share 88% Upvoted
 
wizone4life
wizone4life1,385 pts Thursday, December 21, 2023 4
Thursday, December 21, 2023


A group that doesn't have specific positions seems to mean the group lacks members with standout talent.

this.

37 (+44 / -7)
Share

4 more replies

 
Ftghggyuhgredfg
Ftghggyuhgredfg1,986 pts Thursday, December 21, 2023 1
Thursday, December 21, 2023

" no one is good enough these days to be a main vocalist" ...no their are but people don't seem to care about them.... wonyoung gets all the attention even though Liz has a good voice and Rosie has the best voice in BP but the least fans out of the 4 girls, and already in BM Chiquita gets main focus even though haram has a killer voice. They are there if you want to see them.

15 (+17 / -2)
Share

1 more reply

SHOW ALL COMMENTS

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
Kim So Eun, Song Jae Rim
NewJeans
misc.
Song Jae Rim
Hong Suk Chun, Kim So Eun, Song Jae Rim
KATSEYE
Girls
NewJeans
Girls
8TURN
Kim So Eun, Song Jae Rim
SHINee, Minho
NewJeans
Kim Myung Soo (L)
Stray Kids
New Message

SEND