187

83

News

Netizens debate if SHINee Taemin's 'Guilty' album plagiarized BTS V's 'Layover' album

AKP STAFF
Posted by Sophie-Ha Tuesday, October 24, 2023

In the world of K-pop, music enthusiasts and fans have always found themselves engaged in discussions and debates. 

One such debate among netizens recently is the alleged resemblance between SHINee Taemin's latest album and BTS V's 'Layover' album. 

Though creativity might seem to demand originality, the reality is that many, if not most, artists take inspiration from existing works. This is quite common across arts and cultures, as artists interpret, reinvent, and channel these influences to produce something unique to their individual style and interpretation. Nevertheless, stark similarities between artworks or projects inevitably lead to comparisons and debate, prompting speculation on the originality of the work in question.

Netizens on online communities are debating the similarities between Taemin's forthcoming 4th mini-album, 'Guilty,' and BTS member V's solo album, 'Layover.' The contention arises from certain fans who have noted an apparent likeness in the design of Taemin's mini-album to that of V's.

Some argue that it's merely coincidental and that artists often share common influences, making their work naturally intersect at times. Others contend that these similarities go beyond mere coincidence and allege Taemin's album design is plagiarizing V's.

BTS' V's 'Layover' album design:

SHINee's Taemin's 'Guilty' album design:

While fans argued that the two album designs were not similar, some netizens also claimed that the two artists' albums give off a very similar vibe with the concept of traveling somewhere. 

K-netizens commented, "I thought international fans were overreacting, but the albums do give off similar vibes," "I guess I wasn't the only one thinking the two designs were similar," and, "I think they look similar in that they're both very Min Hee Jin-esque. lol."

Other netizens commented, "There are so many cardboard box designs out there though," "To be honest, SHINee was the originator of all album concepts," "I don't think it's similar," "I think SHINee was the first to make albums like this though," "But it was Min Hee Jin who designed V's album, she used to design SHINee's albums when she was at SM," "I'm not sure if they're similar but Taemin's album seems prettier," and "I still don't see the similarities."

What do you think? Let us know in the comments below.

Shop the story
BTS JIN : VOGUE October 2024
$25
BTS JIN Cover - W Magazine August 2024
$24
BTS V Cover - BAZAAR 2024.02
$25
  1. BTS
  2. V
  3. SHINee
  4. Taemin
146 29,115 Share 69% Upvoted
 
Myrafunmilayo12
Myrafunmilayo124,643 pts Tuesday, October 24, 2023 0
Tuesday, October 24, 2023

Go away trolls

62 (+69 / -7)
Share
 
ManupecksSONE
ManupecksSONE7,541 pts Tuesday, October 24, 2023 0
Tuesday, October 24, 2023

Girl please

59 (+64 / -5)
Share

SHOW ALL COMMENTS

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
Jang Na Ra, Kim Tae Ri
JooE
misc.
Kim Hye Yoon, Shin Dong Yup
Song Joong Ki
Kal So Won
Lee Se Young, Na In Woo
H.O.T, Jang Woo Hyuk
Lim Young Woong
misc.
BTS, Jungkook
Jungkook
Song Joong Ki
H.O.T, Jang Woo Hyuk
Lee Se Young, Na In Woo
New Message

SEND