54

56

News

Netizens accuse Momoland's comeback single 'Thumbs Up' of plagiarizing miss A's 'Time's Up'

AKP STAFF
Posted by Susan-Han Friday, December 27, 2019

Back on December 25, Momoland's JooE appeared as a guest on MBC's 'Radio Star', where she gave viewers a sneak preview of her group's new comeback single, "Thumbs Up". 

However, some time after the broadcast, some netizens stepped up to accuse Momoland's "Thumbs Up" of plagiarizing a b-side track by miss A from 2012, titled "Time's Up". 

You can listen to a sample from JooE's preview on 'Radio Star' below:

And compare the above to miss A's "Time's Up", below (controversial portion of the song begins at ~ 1:27 mark)

Some netizens left comments like, "Again?? Heol...", "They're just so exactly the same that I'm laughing kekekeke", "Honestly the miss A version sounds so much better", "This is just like the same song...", "It sounds the same and the titles are way too similar", "Hmm, more like the same song sung by a different artist", "Maybe they're remaking it kekekeke", "Maybe their company actually likes creating these controversies", and more. 

What do you think of the accusations?

  1. miss A
  2. Momoland
  3. JooE
43 46,648 Share 49% Upvoted
 
MaeilKpop
MaeilKpop8,454 pts Friday, December 27, 2019 2
Friday, December 27, 2019

To be fair, we can't judge the whole song from this short clip, but it does sound very similar to Miss A's song. It looks like after Momoland blew up with Bboom Bboom their company became terrified of trying anything different so they keep reusing the same sound (they were already criticized for Baam sounding too much like Bboom Bboom and this one has the same vibe). If MLD doesn't get some new leadership Momoland's company could end up being their downfall, they've already mismanaged them badly by losing 2 (probably 3) members and ignoring the fans' requests/pleas/threats for answers.

27 (+32 / -5)
Share

2 more replies

 
Violetta123
Violetta12321,539 pts Friday, December 27, 2019 1
Friday, December 27, 2019

It's certainly similar enough from that snippet to raise questions. The rest of the song may be different but that bit was very close.

14 (+18 / -4)
Share

1 more reply

SHOW ALL COMMENTS

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
Na-Eun, BABYMONSTER, BLACKPINK, Cha Seung Won, Jang Hyun Sung, Jang Ki Yong, Seungyeon, Lee Soo Hyuk, Lee Sung Kyung, Yoo In Na, Yoo Seung Ho,  Kim Hee Ae, 2NE1
Seo Kang Jun
Big Bang, T.O.P
CNBLUE
Park Myung Soo
Jun Hyun Moo, Kian84, Lee Jang Woo, Park Na Rae, SHINee, Key
ARTMS, LOONA, HaSeul
Xdinary Heroes
G-Dragon, Jung Hyung Don
J.Y. Park, Kim Wan Sun, Seulgi
Hong Jin Kyung
J.Y. Park, Kim Wan Sun, Seulgi
BLACKPINK, Lisa
ASTRO, Cha Eun Woo, Big Bang, G-Dragon, BTS, Jin
NewJeans, Haerin
New Message

SEND