80

36

News

Fans say the pre-chorus of TWICE's 'Scientist' sounds too similar to Red Velvet's 'Umpah Umpah'

AKP STAFF
Posted by Susan-Han Saturday, November 13, 2021

Back on November 12, TWICE returned with their long-awaited 3rd full album 'Formula of Love: O+T=<3' and their title track, "Scientist". 

TWICE's comeback title track was co-composed by a team of jaw-dropping hitmakers - starting with English singer Anne-Marie, to Melanie Fontana, Michael “Lindgren” Schulz, Tommy Brown, Steven Franks, 72, and more.

However, fans quickly noticed after listening to the track that the pre-chorus of "Scientist" reminded them of another hit K-Pop girl group song, Red Velvet's "Umpah Umpah". 

Listen to a comparison of the two songs, below. 

Many fans both internationally and domestically have pointed out that the two pre-choruses sound too similar. 

Netizens couldn't help but comment,

"For real. I thought of 'Umpah Umpah' as soon as I heard it."
"As someone who doesn't know both of these songs, they sound like exactly the same kekekeke."
"They do sound very similar. But at the same time, it might just be a pretty generic type of melody for a K-Pop girl group song?"
"The rest of the song is totally different, but that one part just totally reminds me of 'Umpah Umpah'."
"Yeah I had a feeling this was gonna come up sooner or later."
"Is it noise marketing??"
"There's no way it was intended, it must be a coincidence but..."
"Apparently for it to be recognized as plagiarism at least 8 syllables have to be exactly the same."
"Eventually, all songs sound similar to one another. It's impossible to create entirely original melodies."

What do you think about the issue?

  1. Red Velvet
  2. TWICE
52 33,188 Share 69% Upvoted
 
honeyydoh
honeyydoh54 pts Saturday, November 13, 2021 2
Saturday, November 13, 2021

I noticed that similarity as well and I thought it was just me. Everything else about the song sounds different, it’s just the pre-chorus really

35 (+38 / -3)
Share

2 more replies

 
pink_oracle
pink_oracle27,112 pts Saturday, November 13, 2021 0
Saturday, November 13, 2021

Very similar chords but I would say there's enough differences to stop it from being a direct copy.

24 (+33 / -9)
Share

SHOW ALL COMMENTS

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
STAYC, Yoon
Hearts2Hearts, NewJeans
Song Ji Hyo
Buzz
Lee Yi Kyung
misc.
BLACKPINK, Jennie
Hearts2Hearts, NewJeans
EXO, Girls
STAYC, Yoon
NewJeans
Hearts2Hearts
BLACKPINK, Jisoo
ILLIT
STAYC, Yoon
New Message

SEND